Stillwater city councilors will decide Monday whether to spend up to $315,000 rebuilding the roundabout at 10th Avenue and Main Street after the low bid came in about 60 percent above the engineer's estimate.
The city's Transportation Projects Advisory Committee voted 4-0 Thursday, Nov. 12, to recommend awarding the contract to MK Excavation LLC, the lower of two bidders.
The committee's five members are appointed by the council. It was created in 2022 after voters approved a 10-year, 1 percent transportation sales tax, and it reviews projects the tax pays for and makes recommendations to the council.
MK Excavation bid $260,723 and Rudy Construction bid $322,787, according to the council packet. The engineer's opinion of probable construction cost was about $162,000.
The $315,000 cap covers the construction contract, materials testing and contingency. The money would come from the city's Transportation Sales Tax Fund.
Buying or refinancing in Stillwater? Brittney, Misty and Angelica at the Oklahoma Community Credit Union bring local expertise and competitive rates to every home loan. And unlike many lenders, your loan stays right here — local.
The council had approved $165,000 for the project's design and construction before it went to bid, The Stillwegian reported in June. The $315,000 would replace that amount.
The item is on the consent docket for the council's 5:30 p.m. meeting Monday, Nov. 16, at City Hall. Consent items pass together in a single vote without discussion unless a councilor asks to pull one.
Director of Engineering Bill Millis told the committee the size of the job, its specialty work and a tight downtown schedule pushed prices up.
"This small job kind of disrupts unit prices," Millis said. "The smaller the job, the more that kind of inflation you see."

Millis said the contract combines two or three types of specialty work in a busy downtown area with heavy pedestrian and car traffic. The contractor cannot start until after the new year and is targeted to finish before the Mid South, the gravel cycling event held downtown in March.
That is a later finish than the city planned in June. Capital Program Manager Jordan Coirier told the committee then that the design would take about four weeks and construction would start in late August or early September, with a goal of finishing before homecoming in early October. Staff did not say at Thursday's meeting why the schedule changed.
On Thursday, Coirier said the largest price difference was in mobilization, the cost for a contractor to move crews and equipment to the site. Traffic control also came in higher than expected, she said.
City Manager Brady Moore said the city could not separate the decorative rock work, which is custom-cut to match Block 34, and landscaping from the concrete work because that would be bid splitting.
"Sometimes everyone likes to round up to make sure they're not hurt on each of those subs [subcontractors], and it just is what it is," Moore said.
Shop Stillwater Sundays — Spend $50 at Stillwater shops, restaurants, hotels or attractions the Sunday after an OSU home football game and you're entered to win a $100 gift card to a local business from Visit Stillwater.
The project replaces the roundabout's apron and rebuilds the center island and the western half of the pavement, according to the city's project plan. Coirier said the work also adds signage, lighting and irrigation in the center island and lighting at the approach islands. Under the plan the council chose in May, the island keeps its current size and the bronze bronco buster statue stays in place.
Committee member Gary Clark asked whether rebidding would bring a lower price. Coirier said staff was not encouraged that it would.
City Councilor Tim Hardin, speaking during public comment, questioned how the new price compares with converting the intersection to a four-way stop.

The council voted 4-1 on May 18 to rehabilitate the roundabout instead of converting the intersection to a four-way stop, which would have meant removing the center island, statue and foundation. Councilor Kevin Clark cast the lone no vote.
The Gose & Associates estimates presented that night put the rebuild at $165,080 and the four-way stop at $339,281, about $174,000 more.
"So now we're comparing repair the roundabout versus taking it out at the same cost," Hardin said.
Millis said a four-way stop would likely have drawn higher bids too, though perhaps not by as large a percentage because the work is less complex.
"If we decided to bid it out, we would expect that it would be considerably higher too," Millis said.
Hardin asked staff to be ready to explain the comparison at Monday's council meeting.
Hardin also mentioned issues with the accessible parking space on Main Street by Denis the Jeweler forces wheelchair users into the street.
"When somebody parks there with a wheelchair, they have to go out actually into the roundabout to get back up on the sidewalk," Hardin said.


An accessible parking space sits on Main Street beside the roundabout at 10th Avenue in downtown Stillwater in these May 2024 Google Street View images. At left, the space is shown with the roundabout in the background. At right, a closer view shows its striped access aisle and parking sign near Denis the Jeweler. – Photos courtesy of Google Street View
Hardin said downtown merchants keep raising the problem and he wished he had asked to fix it as part of the roundabout project. Millis said staff is working on a solution "that doesn't require people to go out into the street at all."
The city installed the roundabout in 2015 at a cost of $40,000, and drivers have struck it repeatedly since, including at least twice in 2021 and twice in 2023.
On Feb. 13, 2025, the driver of a large SUV plowed through the structure, destroying its decorative rock walls, water feature and electrical systems. Only the bronze horse-and-rider statue and its base survived. Moore later told the council that city staff saw the southbound vehicle traveling at high speed through several green lights before the crash.
The wall and landscaping has not been replaced, and jersey barriers and traffic cones still protected the island.
The crash brought the roundabout's future to this committee first. At its March 2025 meeting, TPAC members split over whether to keep it. Committee member Tammy Brown questioned whether 10th and Main needed a roundabout. Gary Clark said its legal U-turn helped drivers looking for parking on the other side of Main Street, and committee member Roger Gose suggested keeping the structure but removing the statue.
The committee also discussed testing flashing red lights at the Main Street signals at Seventh, Eighth and Ninth avenues. The city tried the idea that May, and the council approved $173,000 in January to convert those intersections to four-way stops, which were installed in June.
In October 2025, staff told TPAC the city would rebuild the center wall with integrated lighting, add solar lights in the center island and install streetlights at each corner to make the roundabout more visible. In December, Councilor Kevin Clark told the council the roundabout was too small and its statue blocked drivers' view, and the council asked staff to price both a rebuild and a four-way stop.
McElroy crossing reopens as trail design waits on ODOT
All four lanes of the McElroy Road railroad crossing opened to traffic the afternoon of the meeting, Coirier said. As part of a full-depth pavement repair, crews removed the railroad tracks from the road and rebuilt the crossing. The crossing will be a key section of the city's rails-to-trails conversion, where the project's first and second phases connect.
The city is coordinating removal of the remaining railroad infrastructure at the crossing with Watco, according to the project plan. Moore thanked staff for finishing the work between Oklahoma State University's homecoming and the Texas Tech game.



Crews removed the railroad tracks from McElroy Road and rebuilt the former crossing in Stillwater, shown Tuesday, Nov. 10, 2026. At left, traffic uses two of the crossing’s four lanes. All four opened Nov. 12. At center, the old rails now stop at a new curb beside the road. At right, cut rails and loose track hardware remain near the crossing, where the city is coordinating removal of the remaining railroad infrastructure with Watco. – Photos by Chris Peters
Design of the trail's first two phases is waiting on a contract between the consultant, Benham Design, and the Oklahoma Department of Transportation. The first phase would run from Lakeview Road and Husband Street to McElroy, and the second from McElroy to Third Avenue. A third phase, about 0.72 miles, would continue to 12th Avenue, connecting to Hoyt Grove and Couch parks and linking the south section of the Kameoka Trail to the north section that loops around Boomer Lake.
In December 2025, the council authorized the city to apply for a $1.2 million state Transportation Alternatives Program grant toward the third phase, The Stillwegian reported.
Coirier said Benham, which also runs the city's pavement management program, has been negotiating with ODOT for some time, and staff hopes for a resolution before the holidays.
"They've assured us they're ready," Coirier said. "They're just waiting on ink to sign."
Road fund holds $30.4 million as more projects head to bid
The transportation fund had $30.4 million available to appropriate at the end of October, according to the city's financial report. Deputy Chief Financial Officer Jared Thulin said October spending of about $1.5 million outpaced the $1.17 million the tax brought in that month.
"That's a positive thing," Thulin said.
Collections reached $4 million through October, about 38 percent of the $10.6 million budgeted for the fiscal year, according to the report. The city's project plan projects the available balance falling to about $3 million by the end of fiscal 2028 as more projects reach construction.
Construction on the Parkview Estates intersection at Perkins Road and E. Rogers Drive is targeted for early spring 2027, Coirier said. The project plan lists a February bid date and an estimated construction cost of $350,000.
Bids open Nov. 18 for the Knoblock Street, Fourth Avenue and Lincoln Street reconstruction and for a $2 million full-depth repair contract. A $3 million microsurfacing package opens bids Dec. 9.
Public Works Director Mark White said city crews used 123 tons of asphalt on street repairs in October, up from 39 tons in September, much of it on Range Road. Crews also repaired sidewalks at four locations in October, according to the department's monthly report.
Gary Clark called the crews' street and sidewalk repairs one of the more efficient uses of the tax. Because the work is done by Public Works crews the city already employs, the transportation sales tax fund pays only for the materials, not the labor, he said.
TPAC member Gary Clark steps down; OSU engineer up for appointment
At Thursday's meeting Moore announced Gary Clark, appointed to the committee in 2022 when the city named its first members, is stepping down to enjoy more of his retirement.
"He has been an incredible servant to our community in so many different ways," Moore said.

Clark said progress on transportation projects has been "dramatic" compared with when he joined the committee. He said results will matter when voters are asked about the tax again. The current tax runs through June 30, 2032.
"This transportation sales tax is so critical to the community," Clark said. "So the more results that we can show, the better."
The council is scheduled to vote Monday on appointing Bruce Russell to the committee, according to the council packet.
Russell, a professor of civil and environmental engineering at Oklahoma State University, researches structural concrete and concrete materials, according to the university's faculty page. Russell holds a doctorate in civil engineering from the University of Texas at Austin and is a licensed professional engineer in Oklahoma and Texas, the page says. Russell joined OSU in 2002 after a decade on the University of Oklahoma faculty and was inducted into the inaugural class of OU's CEES Academy in 2025, according to an OSU announcement.
The committee's next meeting will be on Dec. 10.

