OSU Hit with $50,000 Fine for Fan Conduct — Chants violated Big 12 rules regardless of interpretation

The Big 12 Conference has fined Oklahoma State $50,000 for a violation of Conference Rule 12.2.1 following an investigation into inappropriate chants directed at BYU during the Cowboys' 99-92 upset win on Feb. 4.

Rule 12.2.1 establishes institutional responsibility for fan behavior, stating that "Big 12 member institutions have the responsibility to take all reasonable steps to ensure that all university employees, students, and others in attendance at athletics events conduct themselves in a dignified manner and exhibit respect and courtesy towards game officials, other institutions and their employees, students (including student-athletes) and fans."

The conference's investigation determined that chants from OSU's student section violated this standard by referencing the Mormon faith in a derogatory manner.

Both Interpretations Violate Rule 12.2.1

The fine applies regardless of which version of the chant actually occurred. Social media debate centered on whether fans chanted "F the Mormons" — as BYU coach Kevin Young reported hearing — or "Ref's a Mormon," as some OSU fans claimed.

Under Rule 12.2.1, both interpretations constitute violations:

If the chant targeted Mormons generally, it violates the requirement to show respect toward "other institutions and their employees, students and fans." BYU is sponsored by The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints and serves a predominantly Mormon community.

If the chant targeted game officials by referencing their presumed religion, it violates the requirement to show "respect and courtesy towards game officials."

OSU's statement acknowledged that "a derogatory chant followed a disputed call and referenced the Mormon faith in relation to game officials" — confirming the chant targeted referees based on perceived religious affiliation.

A message from Visit Stillwater

Love is in the air this February! Savor unforgettable meals, browse one-of-a-kind Stillwater boutiques, and enjoy live performances in the Original Home of Red Dirt Music.

Conference and University Statements

The Big 12 released its findings Sunday evening.

"In accordance with the Big 12 Conference Principles and Standards of Sportsmanship, the Conference has issued Oklahoma State University a $50,000 fine following its investigation into inappropriate chants which referenced the Mormon religion that occurred during Wednesday's men's basketball game. The Big 12 Conference will not tolerate any behavior that targets or demeans others."

The statement also said that OSU will not appeal the fine.

"It was determined that a derogatory chant followed a disputed call and referenced the Mormon faith in relation to game officials. The reference to religion did not meet our standards and expectations," OSU's statement read. "Oklahoma State respects the Big 12's decision and will not appeal the fine. The Cowboy Code calls us to treat others with respect and dignity. Oklahoma State University values the relationship we have with BYU and deeply respects its community and faith. We will continue to work to ensure that the atmosphere at our events reflects the values of the Cowboy family."

Background

The controversy emerged during OSU's upset victory over then-No. 10 BYU on Feb. 4 at Gallagher-Iba Arena. Following the game, BYU coach Kevin Young mentioned hearing "F the Mormons" chants from the student section late in the contest.

The Big 12 formally announced its investigation on Thursday.

The Stillwegian's previous coverage of the incident can be found here.